Akbar and the Practice of Pluralism
Akbar built the Mughal Empire through conquest, administrative reform, and an unusual willingness to engage with different religious traditions. His life reveals both the political strength of accommodation and the limits of tolerance dependent on one ruler.
History Geeks contributor
Introduction
In 1556, a thirteen-year-old inherited a precarious kingdom in northern India. By his death in 1605, Akbar had transformed it into an empire stretching from Afghanistan to Bengal and southward into the Deccan. His armies made that expansion possible, but conquest alone cannot explain why his government endured. He also widened participation in imperial service and reconsidered how a Muslim sovereign should govern a population containing many religious communities.
Akbar matters because he confronted a persistent political problem: how to hold people together without requiring them to believe the same things. His answer was neither democracy nor religious freedom in the modern sense. It was a form of imperial pluralism, sustained by negotiation, administrative reform, intellectual curiosity, and overwhelming force. His achievement becomes more instructive, not less, when those elements are considered together.
Early Life
Akbar was born in 1542 at Umarkot, in present-day Sindh, Pakistan. His father, Humayun, had lost the Mughal throne to the Afghan ruler Sher Shah Suri and was living in exile. His mother, Hamida Banu Begum, accompanied Humayun through this unsettled period. The dynasty founded by Akbar’s grandfather Babur in 1526 seemed far from secure.
His childhood unfolded largely around Kandahar and Kabul, amid struggles between his father and his uncles. Separation, shifting custody, and the dangers of dynastic politics made the royal household an uncertain place. Akbar received instruction, but he apparently never acquired fluent reading and writing skills. Attempts to diagnose a particular learning disability from that evidence are speculative.
What he developed instead was an extensive oral education. He listened to texts being read aloud, questioned scholars, and cultivated the memory and judgment needed in a court where information often arrived through speech. Hunting and military training supplied another education, one concerned with movement, endurance, animals, and command.
Humayun recovered Delhi in 1555 but died the following year after falling on the steps of his library. Akbar was proclaimed emperor at Kalanaur in Punjab in February 1556. The transition from displaced prince to sovereign was abrupt, and real authority initially rested with his guardian and regent, Bairam Khan.
Their Story
The first great trial came almost immediately. Hemu, a military commander serving the Afghan struggle against Mughal rule, seized Delhi. At the Second Battle of Panipat, on 5 November 1556, the Mughal army defeated him after an arrow struck him in the eye. Hemu was captured and killed, although accounts differ over Akbar’s personal role in his execution.
Victory preserved the dynasty without making the young emperor independent. In 1560, Akbar dismissed Bairam Khan and began taking control of government himself. Further struggles with powerful courtiers and rebellious nobles taught him that inherited loyalty was unreliable. He needed a ruling establishment whose position depended on service to the emperor rather than on a narrow circle of families.
One answer was cooperation with Rajput rulers, the Hindu warrior dynasties controlling important territories across northern and western India. In 1562, Akbar married a daughter of Raja Bharmal of Amber, later known by the title Mariam-uz-Zamani. Her relatives entered imperial service, and other alliances followed. These arrangements gave participating Rajput houses opportunities within the empire while providing Akbar with experienced commanders and regional connections.
Cooperation remained inseparable from coercion. When the fortress of Chittor resisted, Akbar besieged it and captured it in 1568. A large-scale massacre followed; the court chronicler Abu’l-Fazl reported approximately 30,000 deaths, though precise figures cannot be independently established. This was not a minor exception to an otherwise peaceful career. Akbar constructed his accommodating political order through repeated wars, and communities that resisted could suffer terribly.
Expansion into Gujarat in 1572 and 1573 strengthened Mughal access to ports and commercial wealth. Bengal followed in the 1570s, while later campaigns extended imperial authority into Kashmir, Sindh, and parts of the Deccan. Governing these territories required more than battlefield success. Akbar developed the mansabdari system, which assigned officers numerical ranks associated with status, pay, and military obligations, binding a diverse elite into a common hierarchy.
Meanwhile, questions about religion became central to court life. At Fatehpur Sikri, his principal residence from the early 1570s, Akbar established the Ibadat Khana, or House of Worship, in 1575. Discussions initially involved Muslim religious scholars, but participation later widened to include representatives of other traditions. Jesuits arrived from Portuguese Goa in 1580, hoping that the emperor’s curiosity might lead to conversion.
It did not. Akbar instead became increasingly unwilling to allow any single body of scholars to monopolize religious authority. In 1579, a declaration commonly called the mahzar strengthened his authority to choose among conflicting legal opinions under specified conditions. It was not simply a proclamation that he was infallible, as older accounts sometimes suggest. It marked a struggle over who could interpret religion for the purposes of government.
Character and Convictions
Akbar’s curiosity was practical as well as intellectual. A ruler dealing with Muslim jurists, Hindu princes, Jain teachers, and Christian missionaries needed to understand what different communities considered binding. Yet the record suggests more than tactical interest. His sustained engagement with religious debate, and his patronage of translations, show an appetite for arguments that exceeded immediate administrative needs.
The governing principle associated with his mature reign was sulh-i kul, usually translated as universal peace or peace with all. Developed and articulated especially by Abu’l-Fazl, it presented the just sovereign as standing above sectarian antagonisms. Akbar abolished the tax on Hindu pilgrimage in 1563 and the jizya, a tax levied on non-Muslims, in 1564. These decisions removed important fiscal expressions of religious distinction, although they did not make all subjects socially or politically equal.
His encounters also changed particular practices. The Jain teacher Hiravijaya Suri, who reached his court in 1582, influenced restrictions on animal killing at certain times. Akbar sponsored Persian translations of Sanskrit literature, including the Mahabharata, known in its Persian version as the Razmnama. Translation made traditions accessible across linguistic boundaries, although it also placed them within an imperial project of collecting and ordering knowledge.
The emperor’s spiritual experiments are often described under the name Din-i Ilahi. Calling this a new religion imposed on India is misleading. The evidence points instead toward a small circle of disciples linked by ethical commitments, personal allegiance, and initiation around the emperor. Its limited reach contrasts sharply with the broad administrative consequences of his policy toward religious difference.
These convictions had an authoritarian side. Akbar challenged religious exclusiveness while elevating his own position as the supreme source of political judgment. Our evidence also requires caution: Abu’l-Fazl’s Akbarnama celebrates his sovereign, while the historian Abd al-Qadir Bada’uni viewed many religious innovations with hostility. Reading these contrasting witnesses reveals both a remarkable ruler and a carefully constructed imperial image.
Achievements
Akbar’s most durable accomplishment was an apparatus of government capable of integrating a vast and varied territory. Officials including Raja Todar Mal helped refine revenue assessment through measurement, classification, and the use of records of yields and prices. The dahsala arrangement developed around 1580 used ten-year averages in calculating assessments in areas where the system operated. It was neither uniform across the empire nor a guarantee against burdensome taxation, but it made revenue collection more systematic.
The mansabdari framework similarly gave imperial service a more regular structure. Muslim nobles of different backgrounds and Hindu officers could hold rank within the same organization. That did not dissolve competition, corruption, or inherited privilege. It did create pathways through which regional power could be incorporated into the state rather than merely defeated by it.
His court also became a major center of artistic exchange. Persian-trained painters worked alongside Indian artists in workshops producing manuscripts such as the illustrated Hamzanama. Their work developed increasingly varied approaches to narrative, portraiture, landscape, and observation. The Metropolitan Museum of Art’s account of Mughal art before 1600 places this collaboration within the emergence of a distinctive imperial visual culture.
Architecture made comparable ambitions visible at Fatehpur Sikri and elsewhere. Textual scholarship left another substantial legacy in Abu’l-Fazl’s Ain-i Akbari, a detailed account of imperial administration, resources, and society. These achievements should not obscure the unresolved problems of succession and personal rule: Akbar’s later years included rebellion by his son Salim, the future Jahangir. Nevertheless, when Akbar died at Agra in October 1605, he left a state far stronger and more deeply rooted than the one he had inherited.
Lessons
Akbar’s life suggests that accommodation can be a source of political strength rather than merely a concession to weakness. His Rajput alliances and widening recruitment helped turn some potential enemies into participants in government. The lesson is historically specific: recognition, office, and negotiated interests often secured cooperation that military victory alone could not provide.
His career also distinguishes curiosity from agreement. Akbar listened to people whose ultimate claims could not all be reconciled, and he did not resolve disagreement by converting to each successive teacher’s faith. His example invites us to ask whether institutions can make room for different convictions without pretending that their differences are trivial. Other lives in History Geeks library offer contrasting answers to that question.
The strongest caution concerns accountable power. Policies of inclusion remained dependent on a sovereign whose armies could devastate those who resisted him. Chittor belongs in the same historical account as the abolition of the jizya, not in a footnote outside it. Understanding Akbar requires holding those facts together rather than turning either achievement or atrocity into the whole story.
He did not discover a final solution to governing difference. He left a powerful example of experimentation, along with the limits of tolerance granted from above. For another carefully examined idea from the past, read the latest Library stories at History Geeks.